Oct 25: “Love As Our Guiding Star”

Reflection by Rev. Sandra Nixon

Scripture: Matthew 22: 34-46 (NRSVUE)

34 When the Pharisees heard that he had silenced the Sadducees, they gathered together, 35 and one of them, an expert in the law, asked him a question to test him. 36 “Teacher, which commandment in the law is the greatest?” 37 He said to him, “ ‘You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’ 38 This is the greatest and first commandment. 39 And a second is like it: ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ 40 On these two commandments hang all the Law and the Prophets.”

41 Now while the Pharisees were gathered together, Jesus asked them this question: 42 “What do you think of the Messiah?[c] Whose son is he?” They said to him, “The son of David.” 43 He said to them, “How is it then that David by the Spirit[d] calls him Lord, saying,

44 ‘The Lord said to my Lord,
“Sit at my right hand,
    until I put your enemies under your feet” ’?

45 “If David thus calls him Lord, how can he be his son?” 46 No one was able to give him an answer, nor from that day did anyone dare to ask him any more questions.

REFLECTION:

For the past several weeks, I've been thinking a lot about how we communicate what matters to us.

Some of that, of course, has to do with the two elections we've just been through. When you're a candidate, you're forever being asked to explain your priorities. Sometimes you get a few minutes at an all-candidates meeting. Sometimes you get a hundred and fifty words for a voters' guide. And sometimes you're trying to get your message across in a Facebook or Instagram post that someone might look at for all of three seconds before scrolling on.

It's an interesting exercise. How do you reduce everything you believe, everything you hope for, everything you're prepared to stand behind, to a few words on a screen?

And it got me wondering: what if we were all asked to do that?

Imagine you had to create one little square image for FB or Instagram—or a sign, or a postcard, if social media isn't your thing. One image, a few words. Something that would express your core belief. Your guiding star.

What would yours say?

It might be the same as Jesus'. It might be something you would express quite differently. I'll leave you with that question for a moment, because I want to return to it.

About two thousand years ago, Jesus was asked something surprisingly similar. An expert in Jewish law came to him with a question intended to test him: Of all the commandments, which is the greatest?

There were plenty to choose from, and plenty of ways to get drawn into an argument about which mattered most.

Jesus answered by drawing on two teachings already at the heart of his Jewish tradition. From Deuteronomy: love God with all your heart, soul, and mind. And from Leviticus: love your neighbour as yourself.

Then he made the remarkable declaration: "On these two commandments hang all the Law and the Prophets."

Now, when Jesus speaks of "the Law and the Prophets," he's referring to the sacred scriptures of his Jewish tradition—the teachings that guided how people were to live in relationship with God and one another, and the voices of the prophets who called people back to justice, compassion, and faithfulness.

So Jesus wasn't dismissing his tradition. He was reaching into its deepest wisdom and saying: here is the heart of it: the heart of it is love - love of God and love of neighbour. Everything else is to be understood in light of these two commandments. This is the measure by which one's beliefs and practices—and living—are to be tested.

And that took courage, especially since Jesus was facing off with eminent authorities in his spiritual tradition. 

It's also courageous in a more general sense, in that anyone can identify a principle or two that they think is important. But it's another thing to say: This is my guiding star. This is what I will stand for. This is what I will shape my life around.

And then actually live that way.

Which is exactly what Jesus did. He welcomed people others had excluded. He crossed boundaries. He challenged oppressive social norms and the use of religious and political power to diminish others.

Love, for Jesus, was never about an emotion or about being pleasant. It was a commitment - to a way of life that honoured what he knew to be the belovedness of each person to God. And to seeking fullness of life for each one in knowing and experiencing the love of God. 

He knew that sometimes love requires us to speak out. That sometimes it asks us to change our minds. That sometimes it requires us to take a risk, or to recognize the humanity of someone we find very difficult to love.

Love God and love your neighbour as yourself. It's a beautifully simple vision. 

So simple, says spiritual writer Fr Richard Rohr, "that we can see why (christians often) tend to put our attention on the Ten Commandments, or the hundreds of other norms and regulations culture and religion (tend to) place on us. Because it's easier to follow the rules than it is to really and truly love - to love and honour God, our neighbour, or ourselves. 

For one, once we declare that love is our guiding star, we have to be willing to let it challenge our assumptions, our loyalties, our priorities and how we relate to others.

I recently read an article in In Trust magazine about what it means to be human in an age of artificial intelligence. It introduced a framework developed at the University of Notre Dame, called DELTA: an acronym which stands for: dignity, embodiment, love, transcendence, and agency. Five ways of thinking about what makes defines us as human, especially in the era of AI, and as technology becomes more powerful.

Notice that love is listed as one of the five essential aspects of being human. 

Meghan Sullivan, who helped lead the work on DELTA, reflected on how, some twenty years ago, people were signing up for Facebook, excited by the promise that it could connect us to one another and to the wider world.

But, she asks, did we ever really stop to consider whether all that connection would make us more capable of loving one another?

I find that to be a rather unsettling question! One that we probably should have been, or currently be asking about all of the social media and AI and other technology available to us right now.

Now, I don't want to suggest that social media is all bad. Far from it. It can help us stay close to family far away, reconnect with old friends, discover communities of support, and facilitate organizing for social change. Our own church uses digital technology to welcome people who can't be here in person. Those are genuine gifts.

But over the years the platforms have changed. We once largely saw posts from people we had chosen to follow. Now, much of what appears is selected by algorithms designed to keep us looking, clicking, reacting, sharing.

And what gets our attention isn't necessarily what brings out the best in us. Outrage gets attention. Fear gets attention. A sweeping accusation is often quicker to share than a thoughtful conversation.

Researchers have found that some engagement-driven feeds give extra prominence to divisive and emotionally charged posts—even posts people say they don't actually want to see.

So I wonder: what happens to our capacity for love when, day after day, we're encouraged to react before we've had time to understand? When people become labels, or caricatures, or members of some opposing camp? When winning an argument starts to feel more important than hearing another human being?

There's an irony here. We may be more connected than ever, and yet find ourselves less practised at the patient, sometimes uncomfortable work of relationship. Especially of loving our neighbour.

And now artificial intelligence adds another layer: technologies that can produce convincing words and simulate conversation. They may be useful, even wonderful, in many ways. But they also sharpen a very old question: what is it that we need from one another that can't be reduced to a quick response on a screen?

Maybe it's the experience of being truly heard. Of being challenged without being dismissed. Of having someone stay with us through a difficult season, perhaps when we are facing struggles that may make us harder to love. Or perhaps it's learning how to make room for another person's reality, even when it unsettles our own.

These aren't things we can measure in likes or shares. They're practices of love.

And that brings us back to Jesus. Loving our neighbour doesn't mean we never disagree. It certainly doesn't mean we ignore injustice or make peace with cruelty. Love can be fierce. It can draw us into hard conversations and courageous action.

But love insists that even in disagreement we remember the human being in front of us. It asks not only, Am I right? but also, Am I listening? Who might be left out? Whose dignity is at stake? What is the real need of my neighbour and what would compassion and courage look like here?

Love God and love your neighbour as yourself. 

For those of us who identify with the Christian tradition, this is the foundation of everything we do together. We love God by loving our neighbours. And we learn to love our neighbours by recognizing that we are all God's beloved—each of us worthy of dignity, compassion, and care.

I also notice that, in the second part of today's reading, Jesus turns the questioning around. He asks the religious leaders a difficult question about the Messiah and their understanding of the scriptures. The discussion ends without a neat answer.

I rather like that. Even after saying what matters most, Jesus doesn't give his listeners permission to stop thinking. If love is our guiding star, perhaps we have to remain willing to question our interpretations and allow our understanding to grow.

That matters for a church, too. We might ask: Are our familiar ways of doing things helping people experience belonging? Are we hearing the people who aren't usually heard? Are we willing to be changed through loving the neighbours God places in our path?

So, back to that Instagram square. What would you put on yours?

Whatever words you choose, consider these questions: Do they influence the way we speak to someone we disagree with? The way we use our time and money? The way we decide what to share—and what not to share—online?

Of course we won't always get it right. We will lose patience. We will misjudge others. We will discover, sometimes uncomfortably, that we still have a great deal to learn about love.

But that needn't discourage us. Love is not a test we pass once and for all. It is a way of being in relationship, a direction we keep choosing, a possibility that keeps unfolding among us.

And perhaps that's what it means to let love be our guiding star: not that we have every answer, or get it right every time, but that we simply commit to keep finding our way toward one another.

Again, simple, but not easy. May God grant us the grace, forgive us when we stumble, and keep us in Christ’s abiding love as we continue to learn to love. Amen.

Previous
Previous

Nov 1: “For All The Saints”

Next
Next

Oct 18: Whose Image is this?